“Satine should have been a villain” is just. I’ve seen it a few times and. Ffffff please tell me more about why you think a woman doing “my community should do less colonialism/imperialism/child abuse” is the bad guy, without revising what she, her people, or the Traditionalists whose culture (of imperialism, child soldiers, and freaking devşirme, depending on the sect) is being “ruined” by her saying “yeah, you don’t get to kill people for money anymore.”
Mandalorian history is filled with Mandalorian armies committing genocide, both full and cultural. Why, for the love of all that is good and holy, why would you accuse Satine of doing exactly the thing she is canonically an activist against?
People just. Take Satine’s best traits. And transplant them onto Jaster Mereel.
Then they say she’d be better as a villain because she’s erasing a culture whose best traits (egalitarianism, diversity, compassion, a desire to help the weak and abused) are either informed traits, wholesale fanon, OR STOLEN FROM NEW MANDALORE.
Revising canon so that the True Mandalorians aren’t uncomfortably racist and killing political activists for money (see: Open Seasons) so that their portrayals match up to their stated values is fine, but… claiming the pacifist is a more interesting villain because the culture she erased is diverse and progressive in fanon is… why. Why is it more interesting to write a pacifist, progressive character as the bad guy than to explore her in the context of the deeply messed up culture she was raised in.
I just. This is a woman who is shown displaying compassion at every turn and explicitly stated to have gone through hell for her beliefs, who rations when her people do, who said “no more war” because her people killed so many and then each other.
It’s so much more interesting to investigate what she went through. It’s so much less pro-imperialist to just RETCON THE DEMOGRAPHICS (the way canon did) and reimagine Satine as a woman of color to ditch the White Blonde Politician weirdness than to say “actually, the gun-toting mercenaries who said things like ‘the natives are poorly armed’ (thanks, Jaster) are the morally best option for this culture.”
Hell, there’s room to go 'oh hey, Kalevala was likely a planet that was colonized, since it’s not Manda'yaim, which means Satine is possibly descended from people who, like Kal Skirata, were forcibly assimilated into Mandalorian culture way back.’
Just. Why is “the pacifist activist who is on decade number three of changing her own culture from the inside to be less British/Danish/Ottoman/Mongolian/Japanese/Roman Empire-esque should be the bad guy” your go-to?